CASE LAW

 

The protection organs of the Inter-American system have elaborated on the protection of the rights of migrant workers and their families in several opportunities. Next, the Rapporteurship presents the case law of the inter-American system on this matter organized thematically:

 

Right to Life, Liberty, Personal Security, to Equality and to a Fair Trial

 

•         Inter-American Commission on Human Rights, Admissibility Report Nº 28/93, Case 10.675, Haitian Boat People (United States of America), October 13, 1993.

 

•        Inter-American Commission on Human Rights, Merits Report No. 51/96, Case 10.675, Haitian Boat People (United States of America), March 13, 1997.

 

Right to Life, Personal Integrity, Circulation, Residence, and to Special Protection of Children in the Family

 

•         Inter-American Court of Human Rights, Provisional Measures, Haitians and Haitian Origin Dominicans in the Dominican Republic, Orders of September 14, 2000; November 12, 2000; and May 26, 2001.

 

Right to life, to a Fair Trial, and to Information about Consular Protection

 

•        Inter-American Commission on Human Rights, Admissibility Report Nº 61/03, Petition P4446/02, Roberto Moreno Ramos (United States of America), October 10, 2003.

 

•        Inter-American Commission on Human Rights, Admissibility Report Nº 108/00, Petition 11.753, Ramón Martínez Villareal (United States of America), December 4, 2000.

 

•        Inter-American Commission on Human Rights, Merits Report Nº 52/02, Petition 11.753, Ramón Martínez Villareal (United States of America), October 10, 2002.

 

Right to a Fair Trial and to Judicial Protection

 

•         Inter-American Commission on Human Rights, Admissibility Report Nº 37/01, Case 11.529, José Sánchez Guner Espinales et al. (Costa Rica), February 22, 2001.

 

•         Inter-American Commission on Human Rights, Admissibility Report Nº 89/00, Case 11.495, Juan Ramón Chamorro Quiroz (Costa Rica), October 5, 2000.

 

•        Inter-American Commission on Human Rights, Report Nº 38/99, Víctor Saldaño (Argentina), March 11, 1999.

 

Right to a Fair Trial and of Asylum

 

•        Inter-American Commission on Human Rights, Admissibility Report Nº 6/02, Petition 12.071, 120 Cuban Nationals and 8 Haitian Nationals detained in the Bahamas (Bahamas), February 27, 2002. 

 

Right to a Fair Trial and to the Protection of the Family

 

•         Inter-American Commission on Human Rights, Report 27/93, Petition 11.092 Cheryl Monica Joseph (Canada), October 6, 1993

 

•         Inter-American Commission on Human Rights, Report Nº 19/02, Petition 12.379 Mario Alfredo Lares-Reyes, Vera Allen Frost and Samuel Segura (United States of America), February 27, 2002. 

 

Right to Personal Integrity, to a Fair Trial, to Privacy, to Property, to Judicial Protection, Freedom of Conscience and Religion and of Association

 

•         Inter-American Commission on Human Rights, Admissibility Report Nº 34/98, Case 11.610, Loren Laroye Riebe Star, Jorge Barón Guttlein and Rodolfo Izal Elorz (Mexico), May 5, 1998.

 

•        Inter-American Commission on Human Rights, Merits Report Nº 49/99, Case 11.610, Loren Laroye Riebe Star, Jorge Barón Guttlein and Rodolfo Izal Elorz (Mexico), April 13, 1999.

 

Right to Personal Liberty and to Information on Consular Protection

 

•        Inter-American Commission on Human Rights, Admissibility Report Nº 12/02, Petition 12.090, Jesús Enrique Valderrama Perea (Ecuador),  February 27, 2002.

 

Right to Personal Liberty, to a Fair Trial, and to Information on Consular Protection

 

•        Inter-American Commission on Human Rights, Admissibility Report Nº 77/03, Petitions 12.091 and 172/99, Juan Carlos Chaparro Álvarez (Ecuador)

 

•        Inter-American Court of Human Rights, Advisory Opinion OC-16/99, the Right to Information on Consular Assistance in the Framework of Due Process Guarantees, October 1, 1999.

 

Right to Personal Liberty, to a Fair Trial, to Movement and Residence and to Judicial Protection

 

•        Inter-American Commission on Human Rights, Merits Report, Resolution No. 30/81, Case 7378, Carlos Stetter (Guatemala), June 25, 1981.

 

Right to Liberty and Protection from Arbitrary Arrest

 

•        Inter-American Commission on Human Rights, Admissibility and Merits Report Nº51/01, Case 9903, Rafael Ferrer-Mazorra et al. (United States of America), April 4, 2001.

 

•        Inter-American Commission on Human Rights, Admissibility Report Nº7/02, Petition 11.661, Manickavasagam Suresh (Canada), February 27, 2002.

 

•        Inter-American Commission on Human Rights, Report to Close Case, Case 1170, Héctor Pérez Gómez (Mexico), December 17, 1974.

 

Right to Equality and to Non-Discrimination

 

•         Inter-American Commission on Human Rights, Admissibility Report Nº 59/04, Petition 292/03 Margarita Cecilia Barbería Miranda (Chile), October 13, 2004. 

 

•         Inter-American Court of Human Rights, Advisory Opinion OC-18, Legal Status and Rights of Undocumented Workers, September 17, 2003.

 

Right to Residence and Movement

 

•        Inter-American Commission on Human Rights, Merits Report, Resolution Nº 56/81, Case 5713, Alberto Texier (Chile), October 16, 1981. 

 

Right to Residence and Movement and to Due Process of Law

 

•         Inter-American Commission on Human Rights, Merits Report, Resolution Nº 40/79, Case 2777, Thelma King et al. (Panama), March 7, 1979.

 

Right to Nationality

 

•         Inter-American Commission on Human Rights, Admissibility Report No. 20/98, Case 11.762, Baruch Ivcher Bronstein (Peru), March 3, 1998.

 

•        Inter-American Court of Human Rights, Case Baruch Ivcher Bronstein (Peru), Judgment, February 6, 2001.

 

Right to Nationality and to Education

      

        Inter-American Commission on Human Rights, Admissibility Report No. 28/01, Case 12.819, Dilcia Yean and Violeta Bosica (Dominican Republic), February 22, 2001.

 

Right to Equality and to Non-Discrimination

•         Inter-American Court of Human Rights, Case of Daniel Tibi (Ecuador), Setence of September 7, 2004.

 

COUNTRY REPORTS

 

The Inter-American Commission has deemed it appropriate to make reference to the situations and rights related to migrant workers and their families in its on-site visit reports.